Posts Tagged ‘quality of a lulu book’

(My first print on demand purchase)

First of all, The Wraith Atlas, by C.R. Stapor, is phenomenal.  Let me just stick that in the way.  Second, this post focuses on the book itself, as an object (and not the quality of the writing within, which, as I’ve already said, is phenomenal!).

Now, this was my first Print On Demand (aka Publish on Demand, or P.O.D.) book purchase.  It was easy to order, I just went to lulu.com and clicked through a standard online shopping interface.

The book arrives:

The packaging is simple and secure.  The book arrives in perfect shape.

5/5 for shipping!

The new book smell…

As any reading addict will admit, the smell of a new book is an important aspect of the habit.  My lulu book smelled new, but more like a new sneaker than a book.  Astringent glue, powerful dye, concentrated industrial soap.

3/5 for new book smell.

The text:

Crystal clear, on bright clean pages.  The quality is significantly better than mass-market paperback and even surpasses most trade paperbacks.

5/5 for print quality.

The Binding:

The binding is fast (as in resolute!), strong, but not as pretty as a quality trade paperback.  This book will certainly not fall apart but it’s no gleaming gem of craftsmanship either.

3/5 for Binding Quality

The Spine:

The spine is squared but the graphic is not perfectly aligned.  It’s a noticeable cut above DIY bindings or copyshop zine jobs.  You can read the title when it’s on your bookshelf, so it’s certainly functional.

3/5 for Spine Quality.

Total:  19/25

ALL IN ALL, the fact that I can get my hands on my own copy of The Wraith Atlas makes Lulu.com an incredible service.  Who knows, this book may have never existed in print five years ago.  Print on demand allows everyone an equal opportunity to publish, and that’s worth infinity stars.

Here’s a side-by-side comparison of C.R. Stapor’s The Wraith Atlas with John Steinbeck’s The Moon Is Down (Penguin trade paperback edition):

Part II will feature me asking C.R. how happy he is with his Lulu.com book!  Stay tuned…